Pros and Cons to Repairing Your Pews
Pros
• Cost-effective: Repairs are typically less expensive than purchasing new pews.
• Preserves history: Maintains the original craftsmanship, which is especially valuable for historic or sentimental pieces.
• Sustainability: Reusing materials reduces waste and supports eco-friendly practices.
• Customization: Allows for targeted updates, such as reupholstering or refinishing, to match new décor or requirements.
Cons
• Limited lifespan: Depending on the condition of the original structure, repaired pews may not last as long as brand-new pews.
• Structural limitations: Severely damaged pews might not be salvageable or may lose their integrity over time.
• Less modern design: Repairs may not fully update the aesthetic or comfort to match current standards.
Repairing pews and buying new ones both have great benefits and negatives that are important to consider. If the main factor in refreshing your sanctuary seating is cost, then refurbishing your pews through repairs or reupholstery is the way to go. But, if it fits your budget to have new pews made that will help you bring the vision you have for your church to life, go with the new!
Regardless of which you choose, McPhail Church Services is here to help, just as we have been since the early 1990s. While we specialize in reupholstery, repairs, and wood restoration, we have a large network of pew manufacturers to make sure you get the exact ones you’re looking for and experience top-class service.
If you want to learn more about buying new pews (continue reading for more information) or repairing old ones fill out the form below or give us a call at to talk to our expert team who will give you the best option based on your situation!
Pros and Cons to Buying New Pews
Pros
• Customizable design: Offers complete freedom to select materials, finishes, and configurations tailored to your space and needs.
• Durability: Modern pews are designed to last longer with updated construction techniques and materials.
• Warranty options: New pews often come with warranties for long-term peace of mind.
• Improved comfort: Includes upgraded ergonomics and seating options for enhanced user experience.
Cons
• Higher upfront cost: Significantly more expensive than repairs, especially for custom designs.
• Loss of historic value: Replacing old pews removes the character and heritage of the originals.
• Environmental impact: New materials and production processes may not be as eco-friendly.
• Longer lead times: Custom pews may take weeks or months to manufacture and install. Both options depend on factors such as budget, the historical value of existing pews, and the desired aesthetic and functionality.